Did NJ Monthly get it right?

mrincredible said:
When's the last time there was a SOMA Slice-off?


South Orange has:
Trattoria
Bunnys
Reservoir
Pirate's Pizza
La Vera
(Who am I missing?)


Maplewood has:
Roman Gourmet
Maplewood Pizzeria
Trattoria
Arturo's I suppose but nobody goes there anymore it's too crowded
There's Dominos and Papa John's. I'll throw those in for people who like to rant about chains. 

Am I forgetting any place on Springfield Ave? I know there's lots of places to eat down that way. 

Ha - nobody goes to Arturo’s anymore because it’s too crowded?  You must be channeling your inner Yogi Berra!

addiemoose said:
we had really not great service and the bathroom was awfully dirty. won't be back.

Where? 

Pizza variations are a matter of personal taste, not better or best.  Around here, nearly all of the pizza is pretty great (or they don't stay in business, given the level of pizza-making here), so you go with the places that make the type of pizza you like.  But I think these rankings and competitions are silly.

addiemoose said: we had really not great service and the bathroom was awfully dirty. won't be back.

Where? 

Reservoir 

mrincredible said:
When's the last time there was a SOMA Slice-off?


South Orange has:
Trattoria
Bunnys
Reservoir
Pirate's Pizza
La Vera
(Who am I missing?)


Maplewood has:
Roman Gourmet
Maplewood Pizzeria
Trattoria
Arturo's I suppose but nobody goes there anymore it's too crowded
There's Dominos and Papa John's. I'll throw those in for people who like to rant about chains. 

Am I forgetting any place on Springfield Ave? I know there's lots of places to eat down that way. 

 I concur about the need for a more authoritative source of guidance on this topic; however, since the Oracle Of MOL has retired from handicapping, I suppose that an actual Pizza Derby is the only way to put the issue to rest... Ironically, I'm disqualified from voting unless West Orange pizzerias are admitted as contestants...

Nevertheless:

-s.